Saturday, September 7, 2013

Yeah, maybe, but will even one of the corporation generals resign his commission over it? Don't bet the farm.

US Military Leaders 'Embarrassed' and 'Repelled' by Syria Strike Plans
What we need is the modern equivalent of General Alexander Archer Vandegrift's gutsy testimony in front of Congress famously known as the "Bended Knee Speech." Will we get it? Don't bet the farm on the ring knocker politicians and corporation generals of the West Point Protective Association.
I realize that the observations which I have made today are of a thoroughly unequivocal nature, but I can assure this committee that my expressions are based on fact and not on conjecture. In making these statements, I feel that I have acted in a dual capacity as a professional military specialist who by experience is qualified to advise the committee in this specialty, and at the same time as a citizen of the United States who should not stand unheard while ill befalls his country.
The Congress has always been the Nation's traditional safeguard against any precipitate action calculated to lead the country into trouble. In its capacity as a balance wheel, this Congress has on five occasions since the year 1829 reflected the voice of the people in examining and casting aside a motion which would damage or destroy the United States Marine Corps. In each instance, on the basis of its demonstrated value and usefulness alone, Congress has perpetuated the Marine Corps as a purely American investment in continued security. Now I believe that the cycle has repeated itself, and that the fate of the Marine Corps lies solely and entirely with the President and the Congress.
In placing its case in your hands, the Marine Corps remembers that it was this same Congress which, in 1798, called it into a long and useful service to the Nation. The Marine Corps feels that the question of its continued existence is likewise a matter for determination by the Congress and not one to be resolved by departmental legerdemain or a quasi-legislative process enforced by the War Department General Staff.
The Marine Corps, then, believes that it has earned this right to have its future decided by the legislative body which created it -- nothing more. Sentiment is not a valid consideration in determining questions of national security. We have pride in ourselves and in our past, but we do not rest our case on any presumed ground of gratitude owing us from the Nation. The bended knee is not a tradition of our Corps. If the Marine as a fighting man has not made a case for himself after 170 years of service, he must go. But I think you will agree with me that he has earned the right to depart with dignity and honor, not by subjugation to the status of uselessness and servility planned for him by the War Department. -- General Alexander A. Vandegrift, USMC, Commandant of the Marine Corps, 6 May 1946, testimony presented to the Senate Committee on Naval Affairs.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Sadly, the USMC has turned into just another Army, with all of the failed social experiments ruling the day. The leaders are so risk adverse that it takes weeks just to get a simple decision, now routed & staffed unto encyclopedic proportions, instead of the 5-15 min. that it should take to approve something via email. Senior Leaders resign? Hasn't happened in decades & will not happen anytime in the near future...since they have learned to bend not only one knee, but both.